Herod soon realized the diviners had left without obeying his command to return to Jerusalem, making him look like a fool. Without their report, he could not get rid of his rival quietly. But that wouldn’t stop the mad tyrant. He simply ordered his soldiers to kill all the boys in and around Bethlehem younger than two, based on the diviners’ report that the star appeared less than two years prior.
Dr. William F. Albright, an archaeologist with the American School of Oriental Research in Jerusalem, estimated the population of first-century Bethlehem to be around three hundred people. Other estimates range as high as a thousand. Such a small town likely had no more than twenty boys under two. Though not a widespread tragedy, it certainly devastated the area.
Because Joseph had taken his family to Egypt, Jesus survived the massacre of the Israelite boys in Bethlehem. This clearly parallels the way baby Moses survived the massacre of the Israelite boys in Egypt. But Matthew takes the imagery much further by quoting Jeremiah 31:15. On the surface, this verse seems an odd choice since the majority of the people of Bethlehem were descendants of Leah, not Rachel. But even in Jeremiah, the verse doesn’t literally refer to Rachel.
During the exile, the Babylonians gathered captives from all tribes in Ramah, a town in the territory of Benjamin, before taking them to Babylon. As Benjamin’s mother, Rachel represents all Israelite mothers grieving their lost children, just like the mothers of Bethlehem. But despite the tragic context, Jeremiah 31 presents a message of hope. In verse 16, Yahweh says:
“Hold back the wailing in your voice
and the tears in your eyes
because your work will be rewarded.”
Yahweh sent the Israelites to Babylon to discipline them. Once they repented, they would return. Then their suffering would be rewarded with a new covenant unlike the covenant established by Moses, which they failed to keep. Likewise, God brought hope out of the suffering of the mothers in Bethlehem because the mediator of the promised new covenant survived Herod’s wrath.